Down with the Danes
Happy New Year to all Muslim brothers and sisters!!!!
It's not been a very pleasant start to the new year, what with the whole Danish cartoon fiasco. At least the whole ruckus has not been futile. According to 7 days, Danish companies suffered Dhs 200 million in lost sales in just one day due to boycott of Danish products.
And is it justified? I was quite ambivalent about it and even though I'm teetering on the side of 'yes, it is', the 'No,it's not' side still beckons: is any of this the fault of the owners of these brands? How are the employees of this company to balme? Why should they suffer (as the corporations will definitely pass the buck)?
But then I think, Yes, let them suffer ... it means more pressure on the government to apologize publicly. More reason for them to think twice before printing the cartoon (or something similar)again.
A poll reveals that majority of Danish citizens feel their government shouldn't apologise. Some say that's the way to go ... that it's not the government that published the cartoon, but the magazine. But then, has the magazine apologized?
Editor-in-chief Carsten Juste refused. “We live in a democracy," he says ."That’s why we can use all the journalistic methods we want to. Satire is accepted in this country, and you can make caricatures. Religion shouldn’t set any barriers on that sort of expression. This doesn’t mean that we wish to insult any Muslims.”
Cultural editor Flemming Rose concurred. “Religious feelings,” he observed, “cannot demand special treatment in a secular society. In a democracy one must from time to time accept criticism or becoming a laughingstock.”
Democracy my ass. Freedom-of-speech .... my $#@& ass!!!!!
What about BBC's Popetown: a controversial cartoon series that mocks the Pope and the Vatican, that was never aired following pressure from the Catholic Church?
BBC's own website reports on Spetemebr 23, 2004: (my notes in brackets)
"After much consideration, Stuart Murphy, Controller of BBC THREE, has taken the difficult decision not to transmit the animation series Popetown on editorial grounds.
The decision has been supported by Jana Bennett, Director of Television, and follows consultation with the Controller of Editorial Policy, Stephen Whittle and Head of Religion and Ethics, Alan Bookbinder.
Representations had also been made from various groups who feared from the basic premise of the comedy series, which is set in a fictional Vatican, that it would cause offence to practising Catholics. (well, at least the BBC has the head to rationalise on basis of what might or might not offend viewers)
Stuart Murphy said: "Popetown was a challenging project for BBC THREE to undertake.
"After a lot of consideration and consultation, balancing the creative risk with the potential offence to some parts of the audience, we have decided not to transmit the programme. (a consideration the Danes obviously lack)
"Despite all of the creative energy that has gone into this project and the best efforts of everyone involved, the comic impact of the delivered series does not outweigh the potential offence it will cause. (really Danes, was it worth it for you?)
"It has been an extremely difficult and complex decision to make. There is a fine judgement line in comedy between the scurrilously funny and the offensive. (HELLO .... Sanity calling Editor Juste)
"I knew when we developed the series that there was risk involved but unfortunately, once we saw the finished series, it became clear that the programme fell on the wrong side of that line."
Jana Bennett says: "I'm sorry that this programme will not be coming to the screen, but I think the decision is the right one."
So there you go. Where is bloody freedom of fucking speech when it comes to the Pope?
Please admit it, the West (and include any and all generalizations in that: the US, the EU, Christian, what have you) sees it fit to exercise these rules only in their own interests.
What makes the Pope better (or worthy of more consideration) than the Holy Prophet PBUH?
The Danish Government should apologize, as should the magazine and the creators of the cartoon.
I've put up a link to this entry in the comments section of a post on MediaWatchWatch.org.uk addressing this issue. Keep an eye on it if you are interested in viewing the obtuseness of the Gora Gadhas.